I was looking for information on Simi to see if she was on the show anymore and for some unknown reason came across your comment. I looked at the recipe and found nothing wrong with it. Ketchup is a Malaysia/Indonesian sauce and can and has been used in cooking as such (including Chinese), although I am not particularly fond of the warm “Heinz” variety myself. If you liked it when you went to the restaurant then you shouldn’t blast the chef for cooking what is normal in that part of the world. I have been to Vij’s, Green Lettuce, Chili Pepper House and Main Street restaurants and the cooking differs vastly as in any Indian restaurants and regions throughout the Indian sub-continent (it isn’t all about Punjabi style cooking as there are many dialects/regions/religions and people with differing customs and cultures). I happened to have had the best Chinese food (suited to my palate) in India. I have been to the Chili Pepper House twice I didn’t like it the second time as much as I did the first and I wasn’t too crazy about the Green Lettuce. Vij’s also is a bit of fusion so therefore not hardcore Indian. I have been to Rangoli Grill and liked it as well. Also having been to many Indian restaurants there are the good and bad and you must have notice the differences in all the Indian restaurant you have been to ...I am sure none of them live up to your standards or make them the way your mom does as they don’t mine either. I believe this is a Chinese inspired Indian dish originating from the Hakka Chinese in India. The chef is actually bringing forth and educating what is acutally found in India. This is from a person who has ties to Singapore, Malaysia, India, UK, US, Australia and Canada (if I knew anymore countries I'd list them). Lastly, our parents have always fused foods from the different cultures/countries they have lived in...at least in my household they have. Cheers!